How do I stop people abusing my free trial?
By Purlock · Updated 2 min read
The short answer
Most repeat trials use a new version of the same email address. Gmail ignores dots, so j.o.h.n@gmail.com reaches john@gmail.com, and most providers ignore anything after a plus, so john+2@gmail.com does too. Store a normalized version of each address and check it at sign up, block disposable email domains, and save stricter checks, like a card or phone number, for the highest risk cases. Purlock's fake signup checker returns the normalized address and flags disposable domains in one call.
Key points
- Normalize addresses before comparing them: remove Gmail dots and plus tags.
- Disposable inboxes are the other common route. Block known throwaway domains.
- Don't punish everyone: a failed check should never block a real person.
- Keep sending email to the address people typed. Normalized is only for comparing.
How do people get multiple free trials?
| Trick | Example | Reaches the same inbox? |
|---|---|---|
| Gmail dots | j.o.h.n@gmail.com | Yes, same as john@gmail.com |
| Plus addressing | john+trial2@gmail.com | Yes, on most providers |
| Googlemail | john@googlemail.com | Yes, same as gmail.com |
| Disposable inbox | x7k2@mailinator.com | A new throwaway inbox each time |
| A second real account | john.work@outlook.com | No, a genuinely different inbox |
Fake signup checker
Catch throwaway emails and typos, and spot one person taking free trials again.
How do I detect repeat signups?
- When someone signs up, normalize their address: lower case, remove dots for Gmail, remove anything after a plus.
- Store the normalized address next to the account.
- Before starting a trial, look for that normalized address. If it exists, they've had a trial.
- Flag disposable domains, and ask for confirmation rather than silently blocking.
What else reduces trial abuse?
- Ask for a card at trial start for high value products, accepting that it lowers sign ups.
- Limit what the trial can do, like exports or API calls, rather than how long it lasts.
- Verify the email address before the trial starts.
- Look at device and payment fingerprints only for high risk cases, and say so in your privacy policy.
Some repeat trials are people who genuinely needed more time. Offering a trial extension often converts better than a block.
How do I check sign ups with an API?
A check like this takes one call per sign up and doesn't store the addresses, so it adds little to your privacy policy.
- When someone submits your sign up form, send the email address from your server to a signup checking API, like Purlock's fake signup checker.
- Store the normalized address it returns next to the new account.
- If the answer says review, show the person a message, for example asking them to confirm a likely typo, rather than refusing silently.
- If the normalized address already has an account, skip the trial and offer the paid plan or a short extension instead.
- Log the reasons, so you can see how much abuse you're stopping and adjust.
More questions
- Is normalizing addresses fair to users?
- Yes, as long as you only use it to compare and keep emailing the address they typed.
- Does blocking disposable emails lose real customers?
- Rarely, but it happens. Tell people why and let them use another address, rather than failing silently.