Signups and spam

How do I stop people abusing my free trial?

By Purlock · Updated 2 min read

The short answer

Most repeat trials use a new version of the same email address. Gmail ignores dots, so j.o.h.n@gmail.com reaches john@gmail.com, and most providers ignore anything after a plus, so john+2@gmail.com does too. Store a normalized version of each address and check it at sign up, block disposable email domains, and save stricter checks, like a card or phone number, for the highest risk cases. Purlock's fake signup checker returns the normalized address and flags disposable domains in one call.

Key points

  • Normalize addresses before comparing them: remove Gmail dots and plus tags.
  • Disposable inboxes are the other common route. Block known throwaway domains.
  • Don't punish everyone: a failed check should never block a real person.
  • Keep sending email to the address people typed. Normalized is only for comparing.

How do people get multiple free trials?

How one person signs up again
TrickExampleReaches the same inbox?
Gmail dotsj.o.h.n@gmail.comYes, same as john@gmail.com
Plus addressingjohn+trial2@gmail.comYes, on most providers
Googlemailjohn@googlemail.comYes, same as gmail.com
Disposable inboxx7k2@mailinator.comA new throwaway inbox each time
A second real accountjohn.work@outlook.comNo, a genuinely different inbox

Fake signup checker

Catch throwaway emails and typos, and spot one person taking free trials again.

Try it free

How do I detect repeat signups?

  1. When someone signs up, normalize their address: lower case, remove dots for Gmail, remove anything after a plus.
  2. Store the normalized address next to the account.
  3. Before starting a trial, look for that normalized address. If it exists, they've had a trial.
  4. Flag disposable domains, and ask for confirmation rather than silently blocking.

What else reduces trial abuse?

  • Ask for a card at trial start for high value products, accepting that it lowers sign ups.
  • Limit what the trial can do, like exports or API calls, rather than how long it lasts.
  • Verify the email address before the trial starts.
  • Look at device and payment fingerprints only for high risk cases, and say so in your privacy policy.

Some repeat trials are people who genuinely needed more time. Offering a trial extension often converts better than a block.

How do I check sign ups with an API?

A check like this takes one call per sign up and doesn't store the addresses, so it adds little to your privacy policy.

  1. When someone submits your sign up form, send the email address from your server to a signup checking API, like Purlock's fake signup checker.
  2. Store the normalized address it returns next to the new account.
  3. If the answer says review, show the person a message, for example asking them to confirm a likely typo, rather than refusing silently.
  4. If the normalized address already has an account, skip the trial and offer the paid plan or a short extension instead.
  5. Log the reasons, so you can see how much abuse you're stopping and adjust.

More questions

Is normalizing addresses fair to users?
Yes, as long as you only use it to compare and keep emailing the address they typed.
Does blocking disposable emails lose real customers?
Rarely, but it happens. Tell people why and let them use another address, rather than failing silently.